Color cinematography



March 23, 1937. G, G, MORENO 2,074,413

COLOR C INEMATOGRAPHY March 23, 1937. G. G. MORENO 374,413I

COLOR CINEMATOGRAPHY Filed sept. 1, 1934 :s 'sheets-sheet 2 EL?. 6 E910 www l l ggg-W PAH Sno: my

Mafch 23, 1937. G. G. MORENO; 2,074,413

coLoR CINEMATOGRA'PHY Filed Sepia. l. 1934 3 Sheets-Sheet 3 ExPos: Tworissn'nves smuumneousLY To -FoRM lmncss 0F mFFzREHT ,COLOR vALus Deva-:Lo P one naamw: nevELoPoTHER naafmve PRINT .Bo-ru upon ONE Emu L 5mn ORIGINRL NEGATIVE ,ORIGINAL MEGA-nvr 0F ssconncoLoR vmus 0F ONE CDI-0R VALUE PRm-r oF ons coLoR nE;u|.rma mnae. aF PRm-r oF sscorm VHLUE THIRD COITORVRLUE COLOR VALUE THREE lsomoRpHous mnafss or DIFFERENT coLon vnLuxl;

BY y ATTORNEYJ INVENTOR.

Patented Mar. 23, 1937 UNITED STATES PATEN'Iy OFFICE COLOR CINEMATOGRAPHY Application September 1, 1934, Serial No. 742,398

11 Claims. (Cl. 88-16A) This invention relates to a method and means for photographing objects for the purpose of reproducing the same by projection in substantially natural colors. The invention also relates to means and methods Vwhereby three primary colors may be reproduced jointly with numerous intermediate and additive colors during the projection of cinematographic iilm to obtain a rea1, istie and natural reproduction of the original subjects photographed.

- The 4method of this invention generally refers to what is known as the additive process in which during projection two or more positive transparencies are simultaneously projected uponan observation screen, each projected image passing through a suitably colored lter so that the superimposed images create the eiect of the' colors of the filters and additional colors formed by the blended shades or tones of the primary colors go or iilter colors'. Instead of simultaneously projecting the positive transparencies through color illters and superimposing the same upon the observation screen, a similar effect may be obtained by projecting the transparencies in rapid succession.l The images projected to form one completed image upon the observation screen are preferably isomorphous but distinguish from each other in that they represent complementary color values or color values of different portions of the Spectrum.

Although two-color additive processes have been disclosed heretofore (in which an orange and a blue-green iilter are used), the projected images lack fidelity. Three-color systems heretofore disclosed necessitated the use of three separately taken or simultaneously taken but distinct negatives during photography and dimculty has been experienced in producing threel isomorphous images at the same time and in si- 4o multaneously projecting the same upon an observation surface.

It is practically impossible, for example, to cement three separate transparencies together so that absolute registry is obtained between the 45 three images. It is also commercially impossible to print images from three separate vfilms upon a single film in such manner that the images occupy identic positions on the film.

'I'he method of this invention distinguishes 50 from prior methods in that the effect of threocolor photography is obtained by the use of but two original negatives, thereby greatly simplifying photography. Furthermore, the method greatly simplifies projection in that a single 55 master negative is obtained bearing three isomorphous images, the final positive films being simple prints of such master negative. The length of the nished lm, suitable for projection purposes, is identical to the length of the negative used during photography. No changes need be 5 made in cameras used in photographing the objects and but a simple change need be made in the standard..projection equipment for the purpose of adapting the same to the projection of threecolor representations described herein. 10

In brief, the method of this invention contemplates the photography of objects upon two separate negatives simultaneously. the emulsions of the two negatives being preferably in contact. The emulsions of the two negatives should be 15 diierentially sensitive to the spectrum, one of them being preferentially sensitive to the short wave lengths whereas the other is preferentially sensitive to the longer wave lengths. Prints are then made of each of theA negatives and a third 20 print is formed from one of the negatives alone or from a combination of the two negatives. The three prints are then utilized in forming a master negative, identic' images from each of the prints being arranged in successive sequences. These 25 isomorphous images are then simultaneously projected through three suitably selected light iilters so that the superimposed projected images form a composite in which the original colors of the .object are reproduced. 30'

An object of this invention, therefore, is to disclose and provide a method whereby reproduction in three primary colors may be obtained by the use of but two original negatives.

Another object is to disclose and provide a method of three-color additive reproduction in which the nal film used for projection bears isomorphous images obtained from only two original negatives.

'I'hese and other objects, uses, advantages and 40 adaptations of the invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art from the following detailed description of a preferred mode of operation and a modification thereof, it being understood that the invention is not limited to the use ofthe specific materials in the particular manner described but embraceso'all such changes and modifications .as would naturally occur to those skilled in the art.

In describing the preferred embodiments of the invention, reference will be had to the appended drawings, in which Y Figs. 1 and 2 represent portions of negative nlms bearing isomorphous images but differingirom each other in the color values recorded.

Fig. 3 diagrammatically illustrates the sensi tivity of the emulsions'used in the negatives.

Fig. 4 diagrammatically represents a color chart. y y 5 Fig. 5 diagrammatically represents the density of different portions of the image resulting from photography. of the chart shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 6 diagrammatically represents the density .of diierent portions of an image resulting from 10 thephotography of the chart shown in Fig. 4

upon another emulsion.

Fig. 7 diagrammatically represents the densityv of the combined images of Figs. 5v and 6.

Figs. 8, 9 and 10 diagrammatically represent 15 prints obtained from the negatives represented in Figs. 5, 6 and 'l respectively.

Fig. 11 is a section of a finished film made in accordance with this invention.

Fig. 12 diagrammatically represents a form of projection lens which may be used in the projection of the film shown in Fig. 11.

Fig, 13 is a diagrammatic side view illustrating the relationship between lm, lens and light isomorphous images of different color values.

Fig. 14 isa print of the ortho negative of Fig.v 5, an excess of light having been used in obtaining this print. Fig. 15 is a print of the ortho negative of Fig. 5 showing the effect of using less than standard printing light intensity.

Fig. 16 is a, flow chart describingthe various, operations carried out in obtaining the improved color process of this invention.

During photography two negative films are employed with their emulsion faces in substantial contact, or at least facing one another. The preferred film pack is of the character described in my co-pending application Serial No. 710,830 and comprises two strips of photographic film facing, each other in adjacent relation, the front lm, adapted to first receive light, comprising a substantially transparent emulsion carrier and a photographic emulsion preferentially sensitive to the shorter visual spectra but including the 45 green wave lengths -ol. about 530-540 millimicrons. The back iilm is preferably provided with a panchromatic emulsion which records the longer Wave lengths. A red lter may either be positioned between the two emulsions or carried 50 on the surface of one of said emulsions. If desired, however, an orthoehromatic emulsion may be utilized on the front negative and a panchromatic on the rear negative. These two lms ,are passed throughthe camera simultaneously, photography being accomplished by operating the camera at the standard lineal speed. Isomorphous images are thus obtained on the two. lms,

the images differing only in color values recorded 70 tinguishes from the image I' in that the blue and green colors have been preferentially recorded therein whereas the red and orange colors have been preferentially recorded in the image I'.

The sensitivity of the emulsions carried by 75 films In and `II to light of various wave lengths filters for the simultaneous projection of three v represent the red and black portions of the ob- 20 is diagrammatically and approximately represented in Fig. 3. The curve I2 delineates the sensitivity of the orthochromatic type of emul- 1 sion carried by the front negative I0. It is to be but insensitive to the blue. Both emulsions are sensitive to light of the sameA wave length in the green-yellow range, that is, between about 475 and 600 millimicrons. In the event the object to be photographed 15 consisted of vertical bands of different colors, such as the object shown in Fig. 4, then the density of the negative image recorded upon the front emulsion carried by the lm I0 would be of the order shown in Fig. 5. It is to be noted 20 that white and blue have been recorded with substantially equal density. Red and black have not' .recorded at all so that the negative has high transmission at those points of the image which ject.

The density of the panchromatic negative is diagrammatically illustrated in Fig. 6. The blue has not recorded upon this negative whereas the .purpose of producing an image which will be se- 40 lectively transmissive to an intermediate color such as yellow oryellow-green. If the two negatives I0 and II (after development and 'ilxing) are superimposed or placed with their emulsion sides in contact and a print is obtained from the composite, the print will have a. density of the character shown in Fig. 10. It is to,be noted that in View of the fact that both of the negatives are sensitive toyellow, green and orange to some extent, the density of the composite is greater for these colors than for either blue or red. In the example given, the two negatives when combined give rise to a greater density at the yellow than at any other point. vAs a result, the print will transmit light without any appreciable absorption in those portions of the image which .-correspond to the yellow of the object originally photographed. Such composite print will oier appreciable resistance to the passage of light therethrough at those points which correspond to the blue and red portions of the original object. l

An examination of the three positives thus obtained (and illustrated in Figs. 8, 9 and 10) will show that the positive resulting-from the orthochromatic negative will readily transmit light in the blue portions of the image., The positive resulting from the panchromatic negative will transmit light most readily in the red portions of the image. The print resulting from the combined orthochromatic and panchromatic n'egativesl will transmit light at the yellow portions of the image in preference to other colored portions. All three positives will transmit through the White portions and all will oier maximum resist- (5 ance to the passage of light representing the black portions. As a result, it is possible to project the three positives thus obtained either simultaneously or in rapid succession upon the same observation surfaceand thereby'obtain a completed image in three primary colors and a large number of intermediate shades.

Preferably only every other consecutive image of the original negative lms is utilized in producing the nal positive for reproduction. In other Words, instead of employing each and every image I, 2, 3, 4, etc., recorded upon the negative III, only images I, 3, 5, etc., are used. The same selection is made from negative II, the images l', 3 and 5' being used. Images resulting from the'composite of I and I', 3 and 3', etc., arel 39 millimeters of lm length. In accordanceV with this invention, the master lm bearing the triads of isomorphous images from negatives I0, II and the composite, are so placed upon the nal or master negative or iilm as to occupy a length of film normally occupied by two standard picture areas. In obtaining this result, every other image of one of the consecutive series recorded upon a negative such asthe negative i0, is printed upon the master film in sequential linear but spaced relation. As shown in Fig. 11, for example,the image I is printed as I'a, the image 3 as 3a, the image 5 is printed as 5a, etc. rI 'he corresponding isomorphous image of another series, such as the series carried by the negative i0 II, is printed in adjacent relation upon the master film. For example, the isomorphous image I from negative I I is printed as Ia whereas the image-3' is printed as 3a. The isomorphous images corresponding to images I and I but differing therefrom in color value recorded and obtained as described hereinabove by a combination of the first two series (negatives I0 and II) so as to form a third series in which portions corresponding to yellow of the object are sub- 450 stantially transparent, are then printed in the remaining spaces on the master lm of Fig. 11. The image obtained by a combination of images I and I' of negatives AIII and II is represented as Ib in Fig. 1l, 3b representing the composite image isomorphous to -images 3 and 3" obtained in a similar manner. Attention is called to the fact that the length of llrn normally occupied by two 'standard picture areas is indicated on the master iilm I5 as the length I6 but that the entire triad composed of isomorphous images Ia, Ia and Ib are carried within such length of lm. This, coupled with the fact that only every other image of the original negatives I0 and II is applied or recorded by the master lm I5, results in a master.;V

nlm which is of substantially the same length as each. of the negative njlms I0 and II.

Attention is also called tothe fact that the original images, such as the images I and 'I' obtained during photography, may extend over the entire eilective width of the negative film, namely, 25 millimeters. The height. of the images may be somewhat reduced, however; so as Vto maintain the same proportions (height to width) that will exist in the final or master illm Whena sound track is to be carried by4 4 f I5. The image Ia is necessarily narrower in order to acommodate the sound track I1. During the printing operation, in which the image I is transferred to the master lm I5, it is desirable to employ optical printing, reducing the image I sufciently to occupy the area la. This is advantageous in that although negative emulsions are generally very ilne grained, the eiect of graining is further reduced by the optical reduction so that an extremely sharp image of great definition is obtained on the master film I5.

It is to be understood that in producing the master ilm I5 a triple printing operation is carrz'ed out, a masking lm or films of the character described in my co-pending application Serial No. 707,651 being preferably used. If desired, the composite images such as the images Ib, 3b, etc., may be directly printed upon the master lm in the required longitudinal spacing, or a separate strip of lm bearing only the composite images may be produced and then such composites printed upon the master film I5 in required order and spacing. The master fllrn I5 may be either negative or positive, depending upon the character of the source lms used. After such master lm I5 has been once printed by triple exposure to the different source lms,` it is only necessary to employ contact printing in obtaining the release prints.,

During projection, apparatus of the character illustrated in Figs. 12 and 13 may be used. 'Ihe final positive to be projected is indicated at I5 as passing through a gate I9. The lens system is indicad at 20 and the observation screen or surface at 2l. The triad of isomorphous images is projected simultaneously through the gate. The lens' 20 may be a suitable projection lens which has been split longitudinally into two opposing segments 22 and 23 and an intermediate, substantially rectangular section 24. The segments are separated from the intermediate section by means of thin, light-absorbing, or at least non-reflective, spacing means or partitions made from thin material such as metal foil.V The lens 20 'is held Within a suitable mount 25, the upper segment 22 being provided with "segmentmount 2'I may be slidably positioned as by means of the thumb screws 28. The intermediate rectangular section 24 may be provided with means for moving the same in-a horizontal plane and for adjustably positioning the same as by means of the thumb screws 29.

Three light filters are positioned in the projection beam as, for example, in front of the lens 20, such light filters being indicated at 30, 3| and 32. These three light lters are suitably matched so as to produce the desired effect upon the screen. In the event the negative lll was of the orthochromatic type and the negative II was of the panchromatic type, then the color filters may well be of a blue-violet, red and yellow-green color respectively.

The adjustable construction of ,the projection lens permits absolute registration or super-imposition of the three images Ia, I'a and I b upon the observation screen 2l. For example, in the event the images Ia, 3a, 5a, etc.. are aligned with one another and with images Ib, 3b, 5b, etc., but are slightly displaced laterally-'of the film with respect to images Ia, 3a, etc., .then such slight lateral displacement must be compensated for by horizontal movement ot the intermediate lens`-` .4- section 24;l In view of the fact that the projection lens may be caused to absorb any slight irregularity between the different series of isomor-l phous images carried by the film used for pro'- -r -ieetionit is not es essential that au three series of images .carried by the master nlm be in perfect alignment with one another. In this manner, the greatest diiculty encountered in commercial manufacture and use of three-color projection systems is overcome. y

Instead of producing the third isomorphic image by a combination printing of the two original negatives as described hereinabove, a suitable image can be obtained by regulating` the intensity .15 of the printing light during a printing operation performed upon one of the two original negatives. Fig. 5 graphically illustrates the density of the emulsion of the front film uponl exposure to various colors whereas Fig. 8 illustrates the density 120 of the resulting print when a standard printing light is used. In the event the intensity of the printing iight was reduced, then obviously those portions of the print which represent the blu'e, green and yellow colors of the subject photographed could be rendered negligible or trans'- parent whereas the print would be of some density in the orange portions and of considerable density in those portions of the image which corresponded to red portions ofV the subject, as 0 shown in Fig. 15. This iight print come then be used as the third isomorphous image of the final triad whereas a dark print of the same negative (shown in Fig. 14) could be used as the first 3, morphous image of the triad. The llight used in projecting the light print could then pass through a yellow-green iilter whereas the light used in projecting the dark print of the same negative could be passed through a suitable blue-violet filter. The panchromatic print can be projected 40 with a red light filter in the-normal manner.

The sensitivity of the orthochromatic film to Green and yellow in comparison with its sensi'f tivity to blue would control the intensity of light used in rinting and the precise transmission characteristics of the light filter used during projection of the light and dark prints of the ortho- 'chromatic negative. The last-mentioned modification makes it slightly more dimcult to correctly balance the intensity of the primary colors upon the screen but furnishes another method of obtaining three-color process from but two original negatives. It may be generally stated that the present invention is primarily concerned with 5 the production of an image or images of a color value intermediate the color value recorded on two primary or original negatives, the precise modification of the method used in obtaining this result and the precise utilization of the resulting Goimage or images being of secondary importance. YDuring projection in the manner described hereinabove, the film, such as the film i6. is intermittently advanced so as to present a different triad of images to the projection lens during 65 each period of projection. In other words, the 1 film is intermittently advanced a length equivalent to two normal picture'areas orthe length voccupied by a triad of images. Although themtermittent movement of a projector may be mod- 70 ified in a number of different ways to produce this result, a suitable form of intermittent movement is shown. in my cofpendirigapplication Serial No. 726,884, now Patent No. 2,020,564. 'Ihe time consumed during projection of a triad is preferably 75 coextensive to the sumof times consumed during sumed in moving a. normal film the length of but A a single frame. l

`Although in the description given hereinabove reference has been made to specific sizes, it is to be understood that the method ,can be carried out with equal facility on film of a different size and with picture areas differing in proportion from those illustrated and specifically described.

The selection of color or light filters, sizes, proportions, types of emulsion, etc., is left to those smiledl in the art. The particular types of emulsions, shades and transmission characteristics of color filters are mentioned hereinabove simply to illustrated types whichcan be successfully employed. Although an adaptation of the inven tion to an additive process of simultaneous projection has been specifically described for purposes of facilitating understanding, the method and lms or images of this invention inay also be used in the additive process in which successive projection is used or in processes using dye toning, imbibition, mordanting, relief, the cementing together of separately treated films, etc." All such changes and'modications coming within the scope' of the appended claims are embraced thereby.

I claim:

l. In a method of producing films for a threecolor additive process, the steps of recording two consecutive series of images on two strips of nlm, pairs of images being recorded simultaneously, one on each film, one of said series preferentially recording the red color values, the other series of images preferentially recording the blue and green color values; printing a third series of images from the latter series with a printing iight of intensity suiiicient to form images in which yellow portions are substantially transparent; printing every other'pair of isomorphous images from each of said three series upon a single film in seeach triad occupying a length of film normally occupied by two standard size images.

2. In a method of producing films for an additive three-color process, the steps of: forming a master negative bearing a plurality of triads of isomorphous images in sequential linealalignment thereon, each image of a triad bearing a preferential record of a different color value, by simultaneously recording pairs of images on two strips of film, the images of one iilm preferentially recording red color values, the images on the other film preferentially recording the blue and green color values; printing a third series of images from a combination of the rst two series with printing light suiilcient to form a third se- -ries in which portions corresponding to yellow of the object photographed are substantially transparent; printing every other image of one of said lseriesin spaced sequential linear relation on a master negative; printing every other isomorphous image from another of said series in linear adjoining relation to said rst printed images: and then printing every other isomorphous image from the third series upon said master negative in the remaining spaces thereon to form triads of isomorphous images of differing color value'.

3. In a method of three-color cinematography, the steps of photographing an object simultaneously upon two negatives to form pairs of iso- .morphous images in series, the series of images on one of said negatives preferentially recording the longer visible spectra whereas the images of the series on the other negative preferentially record shorter visible spectra including the yellow-green; printing from the latter series with light sufcient to form a. third series of images in which portions corresponding to yellow of the object are substantially transparent; and then l5 simultaneously projecting isomorphous images from each of said negatives and from said print upon an observation screen, each of said images being projected through a light filter of a different color, the color of the lter used with each image substantially corresponding to the color preferentially recorded on the image.

4. In a. method of three-color cinematography, the steps of photographing an object simultaneously upon two negatives to form pairs of isomorphous images in series, the series of images on one .of said negatives preferentially recording the longer visible spectra whereas the images of the series on the other negative preferentially record VShorter visible spectra including the yellow-green; printing from the latter series with light suiiicient to form a third series of images in which portions corresponding to yellow of the object are substantially transparent; printing every other triad of isomorphous images from said negatives and separate print upon a master film in sequential lineal alignment thereon, the isomorphous images of each triad occupying a length of nlm. normally occupied' by twostandard size images; and then simultaneously projecting the 40 three isomorphous images comprising a triad upon an observation screen, each of said isomorphous images being projected through a light filter" of a diiferent color. v

5. In a method of producing films for athreecolor additive process, the steps of recording-two consecutive series of images on two strips of lm, pairs of images being recorded simultaneously, one on each lm, one of said series preferentially recording the red color values, the other vseries of images preferentially recording the blue and green color values; printing a third series of images from the latter series with a printing light of intensity sufficient to form images in which yellow portions are substantially transparent; printing every other pair of isomorphous images from each of said three series upon a single film in sequential lineal alignment thereon to form triads, images of one color value being spaced by images of other color value, and optically reducing the images during said printing operations so as to cause isomorphous images of each triad to occupy a length of nlm normally occupied by two standard size images.

6. In a method of three-color cinematography, the steps of photographing an object simultaneously upon two negatives to form pairs of isomorphous images in series, the series of images on one negative preferentially recording one color value, the series of images on the other negative preferentially recording another color value, and

printing every other consecutive image from said negatives, and an image derived by a controlled printing of one of said negatives, upon a 4master negative to form triads of isomorphous images in sequential lineal alignment thereon, each image of a triad bearing a preferential record of a different color value, the imagederived by controlled printing being a preferential record of a third color value.

7. In a method of three-color cinematography,

the steps of photographing an object simultal neously upon two negatives to form pairs oij isomorphous images in series, the series of images on one negative preferentially recording one color value while the series of images on the other negative bear a preferential recording of another color value, printing every other consecutive image from said negatives, and an image derived bya controlled printing of every other consecutive image from-one of said negatives, upon a master negative to form triads of isomorphous imagesin sequential lineal alignment thereon, each image of a triad bearing a preferential record of a different color value, the image derived by controlled printing being a preferential record of` a third color value and then simultaneously projecting a triad of isomorphous images from said master illm upon an observation screen while intermittently advancing the film a length occupied by a triad of images, each image o f a triad being projected through alight lter of a different color.

8. In a method of color photography, the steps of producing two v negatives of an object bearing isomorphous images, the image on one negative `constituting a preferential record in one color value .while the image on the other negative constitutes a record in another color value, and then printing a third image from a combination of the aforesaid negatives, said third image being of a color value intermediate the color values recorded upon said first named negatives.

9. In a method of producing photographic images of differing color value, the steps of recording .a pair,of images simultaneously on two lms, one of said films preferentially recording the red color values, the-other lm preferentially recording the blue and'green color values, printing a third image from said original lms by a doubleI printing operation, and controlling the light intensity used during such printing operation so as to form a third isomorphous image of a color value intermediate the color value of the two original images. "'f.'

10. A cinematogaphic film bearing a plurality of triads o'f isomorphous imagesin sequential relation thereon, each image of a triad comprising a record oi!v different color valuethan the other images of thetriad, one image of'each triad being a print of onlyrevery other consecutive image ofl a negative l bearing,- preferential records ofl longer spectra, anotherflihage of each triad being a print of only every other consecutive image of a negative iilm bearing preferential records of vshorter spectra, and the third image of each triad preferentially recording intermediate spectra and constituting a composite print of both of said negative lms. A

1l. A ilm for use in reproduction of photol graphs incolors comprising: a lm bearing there- Aon a secondary image of an object, said image being obtained by a combination printing under controlled light conditions of two original isomorphous images of an object, one of said original vimages being a preferential record of longer spectra, the other4 original image being a preferential record of shorter spectra, thev secondary image carried by said lm being a preferential record of spectra intermediate those preferentially recorded on said original images.

' GABRIEL GARCIA MORENO. 

